#Nolan 100

No 52, Greek Figures - Simon Pierse

Published:

No 52, Greek Figures - Simon Pierse

Greek Figures is a small work in oil on paper measuring 164 x 212 mm or 6 ½ x 8 ¼ inches approximately. It is one of six small paintings given by Sidney Nolan to Ann Forsdyke (1913-2007) who was assistant director at the Whitechapel Gallery and, in the late 1960s, Nolan’s assistant in London.[1]

Following her death in 2007, Forsdyke bequeathed her art collection to the Art Fund. This collection, with an estimated total value of over £500,000 and now known as the Ann Forsdyke Bequest, was distributed by the Art Fund to public galleries in Great Britain in 2010. Greek Figures is now in the School of Art Collection, Aberystwyth University.[2] Signed by Nolan and dated 1954, it carries an additional personal inscription (recto, lower right) in Nolan’s hand: 'Greetings, Mrs. Forsdyke, London, June 1957’.  A similar inscription in black crayon is repeated on the back of the painting.[3]

The inscriptions to Ann Forsdyke were probably added at the time that Nolan’s solo exhibition was being held at the Whitechapel Gallery (June – July 1957). Most likely they acknowledge her assistance with the planning of that show which consolidated Nolan’s reputation in Britain.

The dimensions of Greek Figures and the medium, which is oil on paper, both support a date of 1954.[4]  Sidney and Cynthia Nolan spent around seven months on the Greek island of Hydra but did not arrive in Greece until late 1955 at the earliest.[5]  We must allow for the possibility of an incorrect date, but if the date of Greek Figures is correct, this would mean that it was painted before the Nolans had been there.[6] A number of small oil sketches on paper dating between 1951-56 were exhibited at Nolan’s 1957 solo exhibition at the Whitechapel Gallery.[7] They include a number of Italian and Greek subjects. Greek Figures is not one of those listed in the exhibition catalogue, although incidental correspondence in the Whitechapel Gallery exhibition file indicates that Nolan had a portfolio of additional work that may have been made available to buyers during the run of the exhibition. Of the studies on paper listed in the exhibition catalogue, the earliest one with an identifiably Greek title is Minotaur (1956), two years later than the date of Greek Figures.

In the catalogue introduction to the Whitechapel show, critic and author Colin McInnes wrote of Nolan’s recent attempts to conflate Greek myth with Modern Australia: ‘in Greece as it is and was, Nolan has found a familiar country, rich in myths, which pictorially, he is now trying to understand in order to create myths for his own people. The feeling of these Greek pictures is pre-classical, but the forms are those that he, like all European artists, has inherited from classical Greece: it is the mood of the one civilization, expressed in the forms of the other.’[8]

Cynthia and Sidney Nolan went to Hydra in November 1955 to visit their Australian friends, the authors George Johnston (1912-1970) and Charmian Clift (1923-1969) who had left London with their children in late 1954, intending to write novels and live a more simple, Mediterranean way of life. Initially, Johnston and Clift had chosen the small remote island of Kalymnos, near the Turkish coast, but finding it too remote, they moved to Hydra in 1955.[9]  As the date would indicate that Greek Figures was painted in London, in the year of Johnston and Clift’s departure for Kalymnos, it therefore opens up the possibility that the painting was inspired by Nolan’s imagining of Johnston and Clift in their new life on the Greek island of Kalymnos, or, perhaps from one of the black and white photographs of Greece that George and Charmian had shared with Nolan.[10]

Admittedly, the title is Greek Figures and not Figures in Greece. However, the high forehead and smiling face of the male figure, painted in deep accents of shadowy black, looks as if it might be derived from a photograph, while the female figure, tall and seen in profile, wears a long plait of hair extending below her shoulders. Casually posing, the man wears a singlet and might pass for a Greek peasant, but the woman, who is also sleeveless and wears a low-cut dress vaguely sketched in patches of translucent white, is definitely not Greek in appearance. Neither are they a credible depiction of god and goddess, or fauns or nymphs, or any of the other mythical themes that Nolan had started to explore in his Hydra studies of 1956 and which were mentioned by McInnes in his Whitechapel catalogue introduction.

On Hydra, Sidney and Cynthia moved into a cliff-top house overlooking the sea, an ancient house built by Albanian pirates, that belonged to the Greek painter Nikos ‘Ghika’ Hadzikiriakos. Cynthia and Charmian, who both wrote autobiographical novels, shared a ‘nervy’ friendship,[11] while George and Sidney shared a Melbourne, working-class background. Nolan’s father was a tram driver, Johnston’s father had worked for the Tramways board. It was Johnston who gave Nolan a copy of Alan Moorehead’s article ‘Return to a legend’ to read which ‘unlocked a door’ to the beginning of ideas that would eventually find form in Nolan’s monumental Gallipoli series.[12]  But at the beginning Nolan was simply ‘searching new themes for his painting.’ George Johnston describes how the artist ‘had become quite obsessively immersed in our copies of Homer's Iliad and Robert Graves's Greek Mythology.’[13]  ‘He wanted to paint Troy, he said, in its pitiless heroics, in the true brutality of its images, … to give the story back the savage, sweaty, cruel, dusty, unadorned human grandeur that Homer had sung.’[14]

Both Cynthia and Sidney felt an affinity with the Greek people that was reassuring and strangely familiar. Nolan would later compare Bondi life-savers with the ‘poise and physical perfection’ of a Greek bronze figure: ‘pulling people out of the sea and performing what looks to be a strange archaic Greek rite.’[15] In the evenings, Johnston and Nolan would thrash out the possibilities of conflating Greek and Australian myth over a dinner of fish, fried potatoes, honey cakes, goats cheese, olives and wine, all served at the local taverna for about three shillings each.[16] Johnston relates how, ‘when the retzina circled and wild winter buffeted at the shutters of the waterfront taverns, we would talk far into the small hours about this other myth of our own, so uniquely Australian and yet so close to that much more ancient myth of Homer's. Nolan's poetic imagination saw them as one, saw many things fused into a single poetic truth lying, as the true myth should, outside time.’[17]

Yet, nourished by these and living in the very heartland of classical mythology, he still clung to his particular Australianism; he was able somehow to associate the great Trojan epic tragedy with drought paintings he had done, with an Australian background of parched earth, dust, prickly vegetation, death, heat, bones in the dry burning of the sun.[18]

Back in London in 1957, others had begun to compare Greece and Australia. Sir Kenneth Clark, at a lecture at Australia House, provocatively pronounced that Australians were ‘strong, active, athletic, quarrelsome, dogmatic, lazy – all the qualities of the Greeks’. The Greek landscape was like Australia, he continued, describing the Island of Delos as ‘a very Australian place’ with ‘a real Australian light, and those white lions … stick up like white pillars - just like dead trees in the Australian landscape.’[19]"


[1] In addition to Forsdyke’s role as assistant director at the Whitechapel Gallery, she also worked as an assistant on the Turner collection, Tate Britain and later as a volunteer at the British Museum. See Ann Forsdyke (Biographical details) http://www.britishmuseum.org/research/search_the_collection_database/term_details.aspx?bioId=167803

[2] The School of Art also has Burke on Camel in a Landscape (1967, OP206). A further four Nolan studies from the Forsdyke Bequest were donated to the British Museum. ‘Sent to Ann as Christmas greetings, the studies are inscribed with personal messages testifying the artist’s high regard for her. The first is dated 1959 and the [two other] ones on beer coasters [are] from 1966 to 1968.’ See http://artdaily.com/news/38704/Collector-s-Generous-Bequest-Brings-Important-20th-Century-Works-to-15-Museums-in-the-UK#.WV-vCTOZOt8

Also: https://www.britishmuseum.org/pdf/annualreview0910.pdf (p.55).

[3] Mrs. Forsdyke/Greetings/London/June 1957. Thanks to Neil Holland for showing me this inscription.

[4] The dimensions and medium correspond to other works of 1954 that were exhibited at the Whitechapel Gallery in 1957. Nolan did not use PVA medium until 1957. See Paula Dredge, ‘Sidney Nolan’s Paint’ in Transferences: Sidney Nolan in Britain, 2017, p.106.

[5] Barry Pearce et. al., Sidney Nolan 1917-1992, Art Gallery of New South Wales, 2007, p.245.

[6] Unlikely because Nolan was generally quite meticulous about dating his work.

[7] Sidney Nolan, catalogue of an exhibition of paintings from 1947 to 1957, Whitechapel Gallery, June to July 1957, (cats. 110-153).

[8] McInnes in Sidney Nolan, 1957, p.17.

[9] They chose Kalymnos because they had heard that Australian government planned to bring sponge divers from the island to Darwin to work in the pearl industry. On Kalymnos, they co-wrote The Sponge Divers before moving to Hydra which was more cosmopolitan and closer to Athens.

[10] Brian Adams writes of ‘George and Charmian recently returned from Greece, bringing with them a stack of photographs that Nolan found exciting.  Although they were in black and white, Nolan could appreciate the clarity of light in the Greek Islands; and the dazzling whitewashed houses looked fascinating as subjects to paint.’ See Brian Adams, Sidney Nolan: Such is Life, (Hawthorn, VIC: Century Hutchinson, 1987), p.130.

[11] See Nancy Underhill’s chapter On Hydra in Sidney Nolan: A Life, (Sydney: University of New South Wales, 2015).

[12] New Yorker Magazine, April, 1955. Alan Moorehead (1910-1983) lived on the neighbouring Greek island of Spetses and was writing Gallipoli at the time of Nolan’s stay on Hydra.  Nolan visited him on Spetses and they became life-long friends.

[13] George Johnston, Art and Australia, September 1967.

[14] George Johnston, Art and Australia, September 1967.

[15] In a radio interview with Colin McInnes, broadcast in August 1957.

[16] ‘A home that Homer would have liked’, Australian Women’s Weekly, 20 February 1957, p.17.

[17] George Johnston, Art and Australia, September 1967.

[18] George Johnston, Art and Australia, September 1967.

[19] ‘Frontiers in Art: Transcript of a recorded discussion between Sir Kenneth Clark and others’. Transcript made in 1980 but the date of the recording is probably 1957. 


 

Simon Pierse is Senior Lecturer Emeritus at Aberystwyth University. He is an artist and art historian with a particular interest in post-war Australian art and Australian artists in London.  

Sidney Nolan, Greek Figures, 1954, oil on paper, 16.4 x 21.2 cm, Ann Forsdyke Bequest, School of Art Collection, Aberystwyth University, © Sidney Nolan Trust

No.1 - Four Abstracts - Alexander Downer

No.2 - Self Portrait - Angus Trumble

No.3 - Arabian Tree - Kendrah Morgan

No.4 Riverbend I - Francine Stock

No.5 - Desert - Andrew Logan

No.6 Dog and Duck - Jane Clark

No.7 Vivisector - Tim Abdallah

No.8 In the Cave - Rebecca Daniels

No.9 Young Soldier - Clare Woods

No.10 Ned Kelly - Shaun Gladwell

No.11 Bird - Deborah Ely

No. 12 Hare in Trap - Nicholas Usherwood

No.13 Untitled (Catani Arch, St Kilda) - David Rainey

No.14 Death of a Poet - Simon Martin

No.15 Study for Samson et Dalila - Elijah Moshinsky

No.16 Rimbaud at Harar - Edmund Capon AM OBE

No.17 Quilting the Armour - Jackie Haliday

No.18 Snake - David Walsh

No.19 Angel and the Tree - Dr Nicky McWilliam

No.20 Brian the Stockman at Wave Hill Mounting a Dead Horse - Damian Smith

No.21 Steve Hart Dressed as a Girl -Jennifer Higgie

No.22 Women and Billabong - Anthony Plant

No.23 Agricultural Hotel - Philip Mead

No.24 Policeman in a Wombat Hole - Kay Whitney

No.25 Peter Grimes - David Lipsey

No.26 Self Portrait in Youth - Barry Pearce & Duncan Fallowell

No.27 Riverbend I - Ian Dungavell

No.28 Drowned Soldier at Anzac as Icarus - Paul Gough

No.29 Thames - John Tooley

No.30 Girl - Amelda Langslow

No.31 Ned Kelly and Policeman - Daniel Crawshaw

No.32 Tarred and Feathered - Nick Cave

No.33 Self Portrait - Denise Mimmocchi

No.34 Peter Grimes's Apprentice - George Vass

No.35 The Emu Hunt - Roger Law

No.36 Luna Park - Paula Dredge

No.37 Rose in Coffee Pot - Anthony Collier

No.38 The Cardplayers - Nevin Jayawardena

No.39 Bathers - Lesley Harding

No.40 Aboriginal Girl - Jennie Milne

No.41 Pretty Polly Mine - Michael Brand

No 42. Roses in a Merric Boyd Vase - Jack Galloway

No 43. Brett Whiteley - Jonathan Watkins

No 44. Island - Nick Yelverton

No 45. Luna Park - Bill Granger

No 46. Face of the Damned - Kate McMillan

No 47. Central Australia - Leanne Santoro

No 48. Crane - Brian Adams

No 49. Myself - Simon Mundy

No 50. Going to Work, Rising Sun Hotel, 1948 - David Ferry

No 51. Figure at Harar - Andrew Turley

No 52, Greek Figures - Simon Pierse

No 53. Randolph Stow - Suzanne Falkiner

No 54. Landscape No.27 (Convalescence) - Suzanne Falkiner

No 55. Self portrait - Oliver McCall

No 56. McMurdo Sound - Mike Clements

No 57. Faun, Woman, Rider, Horse - Mark Fraser

No 58. Season in Hell (Benjamin Britten) - Anne Bean

No 59. The Slip - Humphrey Ocean

No 60. Central Australia - Chris Drury

No 61. Riverbend - Christina Slade

No 62. Head - Celia Johnson

No 63. Myth Rider - Desmond Browne

No 64. Stockman - Bridget McDonnell

No 65. Untitled (flower) - Roma Piotrowska

No 66. Chinese Landscape - Celia Perceval

No 67. Untitled - Des Hughes

No 68. Crucifixion - Rod Bugg

No 69. Icebergs - Laurence Hall

No 70. Bather in a Lily Pool - Amanda Fitzwilliams

No 71. Breaks like the Atlantic Ocean on my head - Michael Berkeley

No 72. Carcase in Swamp - Elpida Hadzi-Vasileva

No 73. Ern Malley - Isabella Boorman

No 74. Mrs Reardon at Glenrowan - Adrian Kelly

No 75. Landscape Carnarvon Range, Queensland - Catherine Noske

No 76. Abraham and Isaac - Sarah Bardwell

No 77. Rosa Mutabilis - Catherine Hunter

No 78. Artist drawing nude - Victoria Lynn

No 79. Boy and the moon - Natalie Wilson

NO 80. Explorer and Township - Helen Idle

No 81. All Tastes Like Dust in the Mouth... - Carolyn Leder

No 82. Young Boy Who Was Good at Latin - Roxy Shaw

No 83. Mrs Fraser - Anne Carter

No 84. Paradise Garden - David Oliver

No 85. Leda and the Swan - Marilyn Sweet

No 86. Burke and Wills at the Gulf - Jenny Watson

No 87. Dream of the latrine sitter - Ryan Johnston

No 88. Footballer - Gerard Vaughan

NO 89. Sketch for Ned Kelly - Amanda Fuller

NO 90. Woman in Lagoon - Jinx Nolan

No 91. Cherries in a bowl - Peter Blake

No 92. Fountain - Heywood Hill

No 93. Artist and painting - Charles Nodrum

No 94. Death of Constable Scanlon - Anita Taylor

No 95. Untitled (abstract) - David Jaffe

No 96. Digital image - Joe Studholme

No 97. Seated figure and bird - Sally Aitken

No 98. Burke and Wills expedition 'Gray sick' - Gary Sangster

No 99. Kangaroo at Ayers Rock - Pru and Anthony Napolitano

No 100. The Galaxy - Elizabeth Langslow

Instagram